Email a Friend
Printer Friendly
Slashdot It!
Submit to Reddit
Add to Facebook

Fertilizer use not always helpful in revegetation efforts

December 18, 2009

Companies and communities trying to restore vegetation on damaged northern landscapes should think twice about using fertilizer to stimulate growth according to new research published in the November issue of Arctic, Antarctic and Alpine Research.

Not all plants benefit from the use of fertilizers. In fact, some do worse.

Stéphane Boudreau, a Professor of Ecology at Université Laval, and two colleagues spent a summer growing three types of native plants in the northern village of Whapmagoostui in subarctic Quebec. They found that a top dressing of organic fertilizer had virtually no impact on the plants while mineral fertilizer, the kind sold by gardening stores, showed mixed results.

Over the last 60 years Whapmagoostui, a village of 750 mostly Cree residents, has witnessed the loss of close to 50% of vegetation in the village and surrounding area because of land development and ATV use. The result is a community covered with bare sand but no vegetation.

"The vegetation cover in the village is all degraded. People want to live in a place that's nice," said Boudreau. In addition, the region is subject to strong winds that create sandstorms that cause some respiratory problems for the residents.

The village came to Boudreau and his colleagues for assistance with revegetation plans. Villagers selected three plant species to use in the experiment - American dune grass, beach pea and spike trisetum.

The plants were grown outdoors and inside a greenhouse and were fed mineral fertilizer (slow release pellets or water soluble 20-20-20) or top-dressed with organic fertilizer collected from a nearby marsh. Each of the species responded differently to the fertilizers.

The organic material had a neutral or a negative effect. "Some studies show that organic fertilizer can be quite important. It can increase water retention of the soil and increase nutrient levels. But this didn't work at all. It is still a bit puzzling," said Boudreau.

Results for the mineral fertilizer were mixed. Dune grass performed well to the addition of fertilizer, the reaction of spike trisetum was mixed, while the beach pea was impacted negatively.

This was no surprise to Boudreau. "The beach pea is a legume and they tend to grow better if the substrate is poor. So if you add nutrients they don't like it too much."

Based on the results, Boudreau and his colleagues would not recommend beach pea be used in revegetation efforts in areas with similar soil. Dune grass is a much better choice. Not only does it respond well to regrowth efforts, its roots can extent to a few meters, which helps to keep sandy substrate in place.

However, no vegetation will take at Whapmagoostui until ATV traffic is contained to road areas. Although they are smaller than trucks and cars, ATVs uproot and damage new and old plants. "Up to now, they were used everywhere," says Boudreau

Arctic Institute of North America

Related Fertilizer Current Events and Fertilizer News Articles

Fertilizer Current Events and Fertilizer News RSS

Shade-coffee farms support native bees that help maintain genetic diversity in remnant tropical forests
ANN ARBOR, Mich.-Shade-grown coffee farms support native bees that help maintain the health of some of the world's most biodiverse tropical regions, according to a study by a University of Michigan biologist and a colleague at the University of California, Berkeley.

Experts warn rapid losses of Africa's native livestock threaten continent's food supply
Urgent action is needed to stop the rapid and alarming loss of genetic diversity of African livestock that provide food and income to 70 percent of rural Africans and include a treasure-trove of drought- and disease-resistant animals, according to a new analysis presented today at a major gathering of African scientists and development experts.

Farmers to get rice-growing advice via text messages
Farmers in the "texting capital" of the world-the Philippines-will soon have nutrient management advice tailored specifically to their rice crops delivered to their mobile phones.

Yield Projections for Switchgrass as a Biofuel Crop
While scientists have conducted numerous studies on production of biomass from biofuel crops, such as switchgrass, no one has yet compiled this information to evaluate the response of biomass yield to soils, climate, and crop management across the United States.

US approach to farming should change to meet new challenges, expanding needs
U.S. farmers are under pressure to produce more, pollute less, fulfill consumer preferences, and make a living -- all with increasingly scarce natural resources and the uncertain effects of climate change, says a new report from the National Research Council.

AgriLife Research economist: Manure provides higher returns than chemical fertilizers
No significant differences in corn yield were found between organic and chemical sources of nutrients, but a Texas AgriLife Research economist said manure generates higher economic returns than anhydrous ammonia.

Agriculture's next revolution -- perennial grain -- within sight
Earth-friendly perennial grain crops, which grow with less fertilizer, herbicide, fuel, and erosion than grains planted annually, could be available in two decades, according to researchers writing in the current issue of the journal Science.

Scientists Question EPA Estimates of Greenhouse Gas Emissions
The approach the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) uses to estimate greenhouse gas emissions from agricultural anaerobic lagoons that treat manure contains errors and may underestimate methane emissions by up to 65%, according to scientists from the University of Missouri.

Researchers study value of chicken litter in cotton production
Chicken litter is much more valuable as a fertilizer than previously thought, according to an Agricultural Research Service (ARS) study showing its newfound advantages over conventional fertilizers.

Compost Filter Socks Improve Runoff from Croplands
Water runoff from cropped farm fields can contain large amounts of eroded soil as well as some of the fertilizer and herbicide.

More Fertilizer Current Events and Fertilizer News Articles

	Miracle-Gro 1750123 5-Pound All Purpose Plant Food by Miracle-Gro Instant action, all purpose plant food with an analysis of 15-30-15. For indoor or outdoor plants. Feeds plants through roots and leaves so that it goes to work almost instantly. Safe-will not burn when used as directed.
	Jobe's 6005 18-Pack Tomato Outdoor Fertilizer Food Spikes by Jobe's Easy to use. Pre measured, 60 day controlled release fertilizer. Analysis: 8 24 8. 12 spikes per package.
	Jobe's 6028 50-Pack Organic Vegetable Fertilizer Food Spikes by Jobe's 100% organic. OMRI listed. Promotes richer soil. No mixing or measuring. No water run off. Waterproof packaging. Analysis: 2 7 4. 50 fertilizer spikes per package.
	Jobe's 5001T Houseplant Indoor Fertilizer Food Spikes, 50 Pack by Jobe's For foliage houseplants. Pre measured for 60 day feeding. Prevents over feeding. Analysis: 13 4 5. 50 per card.
	Scotts LawnPro Lawn Fertilizer - 15 lb. 53105 by Scotts Use any time of year. Provides fast, deep greening without danger of burning. 27-3-8.
	Jobe's 6528 Organic All Purpose Fertilizer Food Spikes, 50-Pack by Jobe's Jobes, 50 Pack, Organic All Purpose Fertilizer Spike, In The Ground Feeding For The Most Efficient Delivery System For Organics, Re-Sealable Pouch Packaging.
	Miracle-Gro 1002751 Tree and Shrub Fertilizer Spikes, 12-Pack by Miracle-Gro Convenient and effective method for providing superior feeding for all trees and shrubs. Easy to use. Feeds one tree up to 8" trunk diameter. All season feed.
	Miracle-Gro 100052 8-Ounce Liquid Houseplant Food by Miracle-Gro Miracle-Gro, 8 OZ, 8-7-6, Ready To Use, Liquid House Plant Food, In Handy Dropper Bottle.
	Vegetable & Tomato Food by Monrovia Growers Long-lasting, slow release fertilizer that is made from 100% natural and organic ingredients. Excellent for all types of edible crops including tomatoes, melons, herbs, and squash. Contains: Feather Meal, Bone Meal Blood Meal, Sulfate of Potash, Kelp Meal and Soybean Meal. Also includes 12 different strains of mycorrhizae. Available in 4 lb bags
	44 Lbs of Azomite - Organic Trace Mineral Soil Additive Fertilizer - 67 Trace Minerals: Selenium, Vanadium, Chromium by Peak Minerals A to Z Minerals- A Complete Organic Fertilizer A Source of Minerals & Trace Elements Azomite is the name of a special rock in Utah. Early this century geological prospector Rollin Anderson found deposits of montmorillonite clay in a valley south of Salt Lake City. U.S. Bureau of Mines analysis showed the clay is similar to Chilean/Peruvian caliche rocks from which much of the world's nitrate was mined. Anderson ground montmorillonite as fine as possible, then put it in his garden. Results were amazing and nearly immediate. Minerals in Azomite are necessary to optimal metabolism in living things. Ground to dust, minerals are small enough to pass through cell walls of organisms.